Cancel Culture
The LGBT community is and still is a misrepresented group of people. For a very long time, were
dehumanized, killed, assaulted, and pushed aside. Luckily, in the last decade a lot has happened. The
world is seeing more and more talk about the LGBT community, which is now on Youtube. With famous
internet stars such as “Shane Dawson, (bisexual man, currently engaged to Ryland Adams)” “Jeffree
Star,”(gay man in a relationship with Nathan Schwandt) “Nikita Dragun,”(Transgender women) and the
very now infamous “James Charles.” (Gay man)
If you don’t know who Charles is, he was made the first ever male Covergirl model on October
11th, 2016. This was major news as it was a huge step to LGBT representation in mainstream media.
Since then, he blew up on social media and is very well known. He has had his fair share of controversies
involving, racism, transphobia, and most recently, was accused of manipulating straight men’s sexualities.
On May 10th of 2019 Tati Westbrook, a famous Beauty Guru and longtime friend of Charles, made a
video named “BYE SISTER” which is a reference to James’s very well known “hi sisters” intro of his
YouTube channel. Within the 40 minute Westbrook explained her friendship with Charles and how much
she had helped him behind the scenes of what the rest of the world actually saw. She had decided to make
this video “exposing” him because Charles had betrayed her and teamed up with a rival vitamin company
when he needed security at Coachella. She also gave various examples of his predatory behavior towards
straight men. After he had called her explaining how a straight boy who he had wanted to be with was a
“con artist” she stated in the video,
“Oh my god, you tried to trick a straight man into thinking he’s gay, yet again. And somehow,
you’re the victim. It’s really disgusting to manipulate someone’s sexuality especially when they’re
emerging into adulthood and don’t quite have everything figured out,”
She goes on in the video to say,
“You are using you fame, your power, your money, to play with people’s emotions. You’re
threatening to ruin them, you’re threatening to embarrass them, and you’re doing that to have them
behave sexually in your favor even if they’re straight. And you know what that’s not okay, that behaviour
(sic) is not okay. Whether you’re a woman, a man, gay, straight, bi, whatever sexual orientation you are
that is your personal call. It’s not someone elses to take, it’s not someone elses to play with, it’s not
someone elses to mess with.”
Westbrook is very heated throughout this part of the video, she goes on further to explain how
Charles would make this a joke. In a video James filmed with Shane Dawson and Dawson’s then
boyfriend but now fiance, Ryland Adams. Charles was told to stop going after straight boys and that he
can find masculine gay men, he replied with “I mean there are a million of them but, there’s no challenge
in that.” This is what is toxic. This is why the internet is so angry at him. He knows that masculine gay
men exist – he is not blind to them.
Now, how does this behavior tie into LGBT misrepresentation? It plays off the predatory gay man
stereotype. Along with that stereotype there are many others in television that are just as damaging. This
has plagued the community very much, it doesn’t help that there is racism, sexism, transphobia, biphobia,
homophobia in the LGBT community. It does not help the situation at all, it’s hatred that does not belong
in a community that represents how all love is beautiful and gender is not black and white.
This is where the story takes too many twists. James uploads a an apology video, which is
followed by even more backlash. Tati posts an explanation video, Jeffree Star gets involved. The situation
gets extremely messy, the truth is no longer visible. There’s a big problem here, something I think almost
everyone was apart of. “Cancel Culture” is something that’s been around for a while. Basically to put it
simply, when someone (celebrity, public figure) is in a huge scandal for example, a rape accusation, the
internet will “cancel” them. This means, merch will be destroyed/sold, hate is sent to that person, if the
person is a YouTuber, they will lose subscribers. It’s like a huge boycott that the internet is a part of very
frequently. This is what happened to James Charles, Tati made the first attack which has well over 40
million views, this started it all. James messed up, posted an apology video that seemed very forced and
dishonest. Then tati uploaded a video saying she didn’t want any hate anymore, not for anyone. James
then uploaded again, clearing his name by pulling out screenshots of conversations and explaining the
situation through new eyes. Jeffree Star also came in, telling his audience that he was not going to keep
the drama going by adding voicemails and ‘receipts’. He stopped himself because he thought what had
already happened was enough and he did not want an already toxic situation even more toxic. Some
believe that he maybe only didn’t show evidence because it doesn’t exist. A lot of people don’t know who
to think is telling the truth, leaving us, the audience, confused and conflicted. Who is the bad guy here?
What does this say about us as a culture? We go by guilty until proven innocent where we should
really be doing the opposite. James admitted to being in a very dark place when all this drama unfolded.
Jeffree did too. It shows how much power followers can really have. When you have news outlets saying
this and that about you, it’s tiring. These are real people, with real raw emotions. We see them so
differently because of numbers. Some even think of them as Gods, they’re humans.
The real problem here is how these adults did not handle the situation correctly and carefully. It
was made into this big show for everyone but the people involved. The internet acted like it was one big
reality TV show.
A student and freshman from Clackamas Highschool, AJ Sugg for her input on this whole
situation. She was asked if she agreed with James Charles being ‘canceled’ as quickly as he was and she
said “I mean from what I know I think I agree. Because He’s done some pretty bad stuff that painted the
whole LGBT community in a bad light.” She was also asked if she has ever been apart of canceling
someone? “Yes, James Charles and other celebs that have done wrong.” She thinks a celebrity could
really be driven to suicide by being canceled, “Yes, especially someone as emotionally and/or mentally
unstable as James Charles.”
We should not being doing this to public figures, especially if there is little to no evidence. It
distracts us from real problems and is like highschool gossip. The Internet needs to stop this behavior
before a creator or celebrity really do harm themselves.